Ice Maker Buying Guide

Posted on October 05, 2023 By Mike M

Ice makers have been a staple appliance in the kitchen for a number of years. With time, ice makers have only gotten more and more advanced, leaving the average consumer with many options to choose from when it comes to brands and functionality. With so many choices available, it's important to understand just what each ice maker can do, and what kinds of differences you'll see when shopping for one. Read on to find out more about which ice maker might be right for you.

Types of Ice Makers

Though many ice makers function in a similar way, the main difference between the different types of ice makers available is where they are installed.

Hand Holding Glass Under Refrigerator Ice Dispenser

Refrigerator Ice Maker

Ice makers that are built into your refrigerator are the most common kind of ice maker. Most built-in options offer cubed or crushed ice with some variation depending on the model. Some built-in ice makers come included with the refrigerator, while others are optional kits that are sold separately. Optional built in ice makers are typically installed when you receive delivery of your refrigerator. Additionally, some refrigerators include an ice dispenser on the refrigerator door to easily and conveniently dispense ice directly into your cup without having to open your refrigerator or freezer. The main drawback of a built-in ice maker, despite its convenience, is that it can't hold a lot of ice. If you're someone who likes hosting parties, this icemaker may be running low before the night is over. This icemaker is a good option for serving a small or moderately-sized family as there should be plenty of ice for a smaller group of people.

Woman Standing at Kitchen Counter Pouring Ice Into Ice Bucket with Open Undercounter Ice Maker Below

Undercounter Ice Maker

An under counter ice maker is typically built into a cabinet and functions in much the same way as an ice maker built into a refrigerator. This type of ice maker is mostly meant for those that have the room for it in their kitchen, as this style usually has a larger storage space for ice than a refrigerator built in ice maker would have. The biggest issue with this style is that you may need to install a separate drainage system. You also need to have the extra kitchen space. This is a good option for someone who frequently hosts gatherings and has the space necessary to install an appliance like this.

Freestanding Ice Maker with Wide Door

Freestanding Ice Maker

A free standing ice maker is another option for those looking for more ice on a daily basis. This option has the added bonus of being able to be placed anywhere with access to power. Like the undercounter option, you also may need to potentially find a way to drain it. This kind of icemaker is great for anyone looking for more ice without installing a built-in unit.

Ice Maker Sitting on Countertop with Ice Scoop Resting in Front

Countertop Ice Maker

If you're looking for larger amounts of ice, countertop ice makers are a good choice. The best part about them is that they're meant to sit conveniently atop your kitchen counter, making them easy to access after you pour yourself a nice cold beverage. If you're trying to save freezer space by avoiding using a built-in ice maker and ice trays, but still have a need for more generous amounts of ice, this ice maker could be right for your kitchen.

Ice Maker as Part of Outdoor Kitchen on Deck

Outdoor Ice Maker

Outdoor ice makers are great for those who love to spend their time outside, or frequently entertain poolside or near the grill. They can stand alone, or be installed as part of an outdoor kitchen. Though these models can be very convenient during the summertime, it can sometimes require more energy than the average ice maker to stay cool.

Types of Ice

Another defining feature of a given ice maker is the kind of ice it can make. There are more ice shapes out there than just cubes!

Ice Cubes in Glass

Cube Ice Maker

Of course, the classic ice cube is the most common ice shape. With each cube being a good enough size to keep a beverage cool without being too big to fit in the cup, cubes are a never-fail option. When these show up as an option for an ice maker to dispense, you can typically have them come out crushed as well.

Crescent Ice Cubes in Glass

Crescent Ice Maker

Crescents function in much the same way as cubes do, but the shape is less likely to pack together, and also tends to cause less of a splash when dropping into a beverage. Most ice makers that make use of this shape also typically have an option to serve it crushed.

Two Festive Pink Drinks Garnished with Watermelon and Filled with Pellet Ice

Pellet Ice Maker

Ice shaped like nuggets or pellets is great for carbonated drinks. This is due to their ability to reduce fizz. This ice shape also tends to cover a large surface area when compared to other ice shapes, allowing for quick cooling. They also have the added benefit of being fun to chew on!

Large Orb of Craft Ice in Whisky Glass

Craft Ice Maker

Craft ice has a large spherical shape and it is typically used in cocktails. The dense shape is designed to melt extra slowly for extended cooling of your beverage without watering it down. Craft ice is a go-to for use with high-quality liquors and spirits.

A high-quality ice maker should last you a long time. With all these options available, make sure you choose one that will best meet your needs!